 Bones | 1 | Always |
 Water rune | 3 | 10/128 |
 Raw tuna | 1 | 10/128 |
 Raw herring | 1 | 5/128 |
 Raw sardine | 1 | 10/128 |
 Coins | 16 | 10/128 |
| Coins | 25 | 10/128 |
 Seaweed | 1 | 10/128 |
 Feather | 2 | 38/128 |
 Fishing bait | 3 | 10/128 |
 Oyster pearl | 1 | 4/128 |
 Water talisman | 1 | 10/128 |
 Uncut sapphire | 1 | 1/512 |
 Uncut emerald | 1 | 1/1,024 |
 Uncut ruby | 1 | 1/2,048 |
 Chaos talisman | 1 | 1/5,461.33 |
 Uncut diamond | 1 | 1/8,192 |
 Rune javelin (Unpoisoned) | 5 | 1/16,384 |
 Loop half of key | 1 | 1/16,384 |
 Tooth half of key | 1 | 1/16,384 |
 Rune spear ((unp)) | 1 | 1/262,144 |
 Shield left half | 1 | 1/524,288 |
 Dragon spear ((unp)) | 1 | 1/699,050.67 |
 Dagannoth ribs (Unpolished) | 1 | 1/4 |
 Clue scroll (easy) | 1 | 1/128 |
 Brimstone key | 1 | 1/772 |