Caramel cup: where to get it
| Source | Quantity | Chance per roll |
|---|---|---|
| Christmas loot piñata (2018) (2018 Christmas Loot piñatas) [] | 1 | Unknown |
| Christmas loot piñata (2017 (From other players' piñatas)) [] | 1 | Unknown |
| Christmas piñata loot bag [] | 1 | Common |
| Christmas piñata loot bag (2018) [] | 1 | Common |
| Loot piñata (From other players' piñatas) [] | 1 | Unknown |
| Lovely gift box [] | 1 | 142/1,000 |
| Lovely gift box (Ironman Mode) [] | 1 | 142/1,000 |
| Piñata loot bag [] | 1 | Common |
| Summer piñata [] | 1 | Common |
| Summer piñata (2022) (Intact) [] | 1 | Common |
| Summer piñata loot bag [] | 1 | Rare |
| Summer piñata loot bag (2018) [] | 1 | Common |
| Summer piñata loot bag (2022) [] | 1 | Uncommon |
| Valentine's Shop (2014 chocolates) [] | 1 | 1/6 |