| Ogress | 1 | 6.54/1,000 |
| Ogress champion | 1 | 7.7/1,000 |
| Ogress warrior | 1 | 5.56/1,000 |
| Ol' Sawtooth (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Olivia the Chronicler (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Onyx dragon | 1 | 13.4/1,000 |
| Onyx dragon (Dragonkin Laboratory) (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Oreb, the Magister (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Oyu the Quietest (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Pee Hat | 1 | 10.4/1,000 |
| Pirate plunder Estimated rarity may be inaccurate due to a low sample size. | 25 | 5/267 |
| Pirate plunder (small) Estimated rarity may be inaccurate due to a low sample size. | 25 | 5/267 |
| Possessed pickaxe (Lair of Tarn Razorlor) | 1 | 18.7/1,000 |
| Profane Scabarite | 2 | 10/100 |
| Pyrefiend | 1 | 2.32/1,000 |
| Pyrefiend (God Wars Dungeon) | 1 | 2.32/1,000 |
| Quetzathog (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Raptor's chest of slaying | 75 | Always |
| Ravenous ghoul | 1 | 9.97/1,000 |
| Red dragon | 1 | 36.2/1,000 |
| Red dragon (Dragonkin Laboratory) (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Reinforced chest (Dorgesh-Kaan) | 1–2 | Common |
| Renegade Menaphite soldier (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Ripper Demon | 4 | 249/1,000 |
| Ripper dinosaur | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Rock | 1 | 10.4/1,000 |
| Rock crab | 1 | 1.81/1,000 |
| Rock lobster | 2 | 9.4/1,000 |
| Rogue | 1 | 1.26/1,000 |
| Rorarius | 1 | 6.74/1,000 |
| Rune dragon | 4 | 51.8/1,000 |
| Salawa akh | 1 | 8.96/1,000 |
| Sangri the Red (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Sanguine crawler | 1 | 5.3/1,000 |
| Sarkhan the Serpentspeaker (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Scarab akh | 1 | 8.96/1,000 |
| Scutarius | 1 | 241/1,000 |
| Sea crocodile (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Sea horror (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Seeker | 1 | 8.96/1,000 |
| Seiryu the Azure Serpent (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Shadow warrior | 1 | 5.32/1,000 |
| Shiny columbarium key | 1 | 55.3/1,000 |
| Shrine Maiden Elei (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Shul the Molten (Normal mode) | 1 | 255/1,000 |
| Skeletal hand | 1 | 3.36/1,000 |
| Skeletal Wyvern | 2 | 13.7/1,000 |
| Skeleton (Level 45) | 1 | 19.9/1,000 |