| Moss giant | 35–45 | 1/131,072 |
| Moss golem | 35–45 | Very rare |
| Mountain troll | 35–45 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Mourner (Mourner Tunnels) | 35–45 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht Pyramid) | 35–45 | 1/1,050,624 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht sarcophagus) | 35–45 | 1/1,050,624 |
| Mummy (Ullek) | 35–45 | 1/1,050,624 |
| Mutated bloodveld | 35–45 | 1/52,428.8 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 58) | 35–45 | 1/131,072 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 65) | 35–45 | 1/131,072 |
| Mystery gift (Christmas Village) Estimated rarity may be inaccurate due to a low sample size. | 25 | 12/96, 3 rolls |
| Nechryael | 35–45 | 1/7,539.81 |
| Nechryael (elite) | 35–45 | 1/3,035.32, 3 rolls |
| Nechryael (Heart of Gielinor) | 35–45 | 1/103,219.2 |
| Necromancer (Heart of Gielinor) | 35–45 | 1/103,219.2 |
Nex (Normal) | 35–45 | 1/1,600, 2 rolls |
| Nightmare | 35–45 | 1/3,200 |
| Nikita | 35–45 | 1/2,097,152 |
| Nikolai | 35–45 | 1/2,097,152 |
| Nodon artificer | 35–45 | 1/3,200 |
| Nodon enforcer | 35–45 | 1/3,200 |
| Nodon engineer | 35–45 | 1/3,200 |
| Nodon guard | 35–45 | 1/3,200 |
| Nodon hunter | 35–45 | 1/3,200 |
| Ogre statue | 35–45 | 1/258,048 |
| Ol' Sawtooth (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Olivia the Chronicler (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Onyx dragon | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Onyx dragon (Dragonkin Laboratory) (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Oreb, the Magister (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Orikalka | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Ork statue | 35–45 | 1/404,821.33 |
| Osseous | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Otherworldly being | 35–45 | 1/177,536.68 |
| Ourg statue | 35–45 | 1/2,972.23 |
| Oyu the Quietest (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Paladin | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Pee Hat | 35–45 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Pirate | 35–45 | 1/524,288 |
| Pit iron dragon (Love Story) | 1 | Always |
| Poison black dragon | 1 | Always |
| Profane Scabarite | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Pthentraken | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Pyrefiend | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Pyrefiend (God Wars Dungeon) | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Queen Black Dragon | 8 | Always |
| Queen Black Dragon | 35–45 | 1/872 |
| Quetzathog (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |