| Mature grotworm | 1 | 1/464 |
| Mighty banshee | 1 | 1/182, 2 rolls |
| Mighty Blood reaver | 1 | 1/1,032.5 |
| Milla | 1 | 1/10,922.7 |
| Molanisk | 1 | 1/170.7 |
| Monk of Chaos (Normal mode) | 2–4 | 1/95.2 |
| Monk of Chaos (Story mode) | 1 | 400/10,000 |
| Moss giant | 1 | 1/1,092.3 |
| Moss golem | 1–3 | 15/136 |
| Mountain troll | 1 | 1/364.1 |
| Mourner (Mourner Tunnels) | 1 | 1/364.1 |
| Mugger | 1 | 1/420.1 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht Pyramid) | 1 | 1/7,296 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht sarcophagus) | 1 | 1/7,296 |
| Mummy (Ullek) | 1 | 1/7,296 |
| Mutated jadinko baby | 1 | 1/247.6 |
| Mutated jadinko guard | 1 | 1/247.6 |
| Mutated jadinko male | 1 | 1/247.6 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 58) | 1 | 1/546.1 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 65) | 1 | 1/546.1 |
| Mystery box (Court Cases) Using an estimated rarity as not enough data has been submitted. | 8 | Uncommon |
| Narf | 1 | 1/237.4 |
| Nechryael (Heart of Gielinor) | 1 | 1/1,075.2 |
| Necromancer (Heart of Gielinor) | 1 | 1/1,075.2 |
| Neem oil | 1 | Uncommon |
| Nikita | 1 | 1/10,922.7 |
| Nikolai | 1 | 1/10,922.7 |
| Oculi apoterrasaur | 10 | 15/1,000 |
| Ogre Coffin | 1 | 125/12,800 |
| Otherworldly being | 1 | 1/554.8 |
| Outlaw | 1 | 1/170.7 |
| Paladin | 1 | 1/682.7 |
| Pavosaurus rex | 10 | Common |
| Pee Hat | 1 | 1/364.1 |
| Pyrefiend (The Zamorakian Undercity) | 1 | Common |
| Raptor's chest of slaying | 25 | Always |
| Ravenous ghoul | 1 | 1/682.7 |
| Red dragon | 1 | 1/2,730.7 |
| Reward token (Red) | 2–7 | Unknown |
| Rewards (Barbarian Assault) (Gamble points - high items) | 11 | Common |
| Rewards (Barbarian Assault) (Gamble points - low items) | 3 | Uncommon |
| Rock | 1 | 1/364.1 |
| Rock lobster | 1 | 1/1,820.4 |
| Rogue | 1 | 1/237.4 |
| Rogue Captain | 1 | 1/237.4 |
| Rogue Enforcer | 1 | 1/237.4 |
| Rorarius | 1 | 1/454.8 |
| Rusty | 1 | 1/237.4 |