| Ice troll male (Variant 2) | 1 | 1/41,943.04 |
| Ice troll male (Variant 2) | 18–22 | 1/2,236,962.13 |
| Ice troll runt | 1 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Ice troll runt | 18–22 | 1/5,592,405.33 |
| Ice troll runt (Variant 2) | 1 | 1/41,943.04 |
| Ice troll runt (Variant 2) | 18–22 | 1/2,236,962.13 |
| Ice warrior | 1 | 1/209,715.2 |
| Ice warrior | 18–22 | 1/11,184,810.67 |
| Icefiend (Ghorrock) | 1 | 1/52,428.8 |
| Icefiend (Ghorrock) | 18–22 | 1/2,796,202.67 |
| Icefiend (God Wars Dungeon) | 1 | 1/69,905.07 |
| Icefiend (God Wars Dungeon) | 18–22 | 1/3,728,270.22 |
| Imperial mage akh | 1 | 1/1,920 |
| Imperial mage akh | 18–22 | 1/102,400 |
| Imperial ranger akh | 1 | 1/1,920 |
| Imperial ranger akh | 18–22 | 1/102,400 |
| Imperial warrior akh | 1 | 1/1,920 |
| Imperial warrior akh | 18–22 | 1/102,400 |
| Imre | 1 | 1/838,860.8 |
| Imre | 18–22 | 1/44,739,242.67 |
| Infernal Mage (elite) | 1 | 1/13,107.2, 3 rolls |
| Infernal Mage (elite) | 18–22 | 1/699,050.67, 3 rolls |
| Iorwerth guard | 1 | 6/128 |
| Iorwerth guard | 1 | 1/3,200 |
| Iorwerth guard | 18–22 | 1/170,666.67 |
| Iorwerth scout | 1 | 6/128 |
| Iorwerth scout | 1 | 1/3,200 |
| Iorwerth scout | 18–22 | 1/170,666.67 |
| Irina | 1 | 1/838,860.8 |
| Irina | 18–22 | 1/44,739,242.67 |
| Iron dragon | 1 | 1/2,973.17 |
| Iron dragon | 18–22 | 1/158,568.83 |
| Jade the Unruly (Normal mode) | 1 | 1/1,920 |
| Jade the Unruly (Normal mode) | 18–22 | 1/102,400 |
| Jelly | 1 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Jelly | 18–22 | 1/5,592,405.33 |
| Jennella | 1 | 1/838,860.8 |
| Jennella | 18–22 | 1/44,739,242.67 |
| Jeroen | 1 | 1/838,860.8 |
| Jeroen | 18–22 | 1/44,739,242.67 |
| Jogre | 1 | 1/211,353.6 |
| Jogre | 18–22 | 1/11,272,192 |
| Jogre (God Wars Dungeon) | 1 | 1/211,353.6 |
| Jogre (God Wars Dungeon) | 18–22 | 1/11,272,192 |
| Joseph | 1 | 1/838,860.8 |
| Joseph | 18–22 | 1/44,739,242.67 |
| Jungle strykewyrm | 1 | 1/41,369.6 |
| Jungle strykewyrm | 18–22 | 1/2,206,378.67 |