| Lesser demon | 1 | 1/170.67 |
| Lesser demon (Demon Flash Mobs) | 1 | 1/170.67 |
| Lesser demon (Wizards' Tower) | 1 | 1/170.67 |
| Lesser reborn mage | 1 | 1/228.57 |
| Lesser reborn ranger | 1 | 1/228.57 |
| Lesser reborn warrior | 1 | 1/228.57 |
| Lev | 1 | 1/8,192 |
| Liliya | 1 | 1/8,192 |
| Living rock protector | 1 | 2/138 |
| Living rock striker | 1 | 3/138 |
| Lizard | 1 | 1/409.6 |
| Locust lancer | 1 | 1/146.29, 2 rolls |
| Locust ranger | 1 | 1/146.29, 2 rolls |
| Locust rider | 1 | 1/146.29 |
| Magical chest (Tier 5) | 3–10 | Varies |
| Magpie Estimated rarity may be inaccurate due to a low sample size. | 1 | 61/854 |
| Mahogany casket | 3 | 4/64 |
| Managing Miscellania (Fishing) | 1 | Common |
| Managing Miscellania (Fishing (cooked)) | 1 | Unknown |
| Managing Miscellania (Mining) | 1 | Common |
| Manifest shadow | 1 | 1/550 |
| Market Guard (Fremennik) | 1 | 1/2,048 |
| Medium loot chest | 5 | 12/100 |
| Mighty Blood reaver | 1 | 1/387.2 |
| Milla | 1 | 1/8,192 |
| Minotaur | 1 | 1/2,048 |
| Minotaur (Turael's basement) | 1 | 1/2,048 |
| Mithril dragon | 1 | 1/406.4 |
| Molanisk | 1 | 1/292.57 |
| Moss giant | 1 | 1/512 |
| Moss golem | 3 | 15/136 |
| Mountain troll | 1 | 1/409.6 |
| Mourner (Mourner Tunnels) | 1 | 1/409.6 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht Pyramid) | 1 | 1/4,104 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht sarcophagus) | 1 | 1/4,104 |
| Mummy (Ullek) | 1 | 1/4,104 |
| Mutated bloodveld | 1 | 1/204.8 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 58) | 1 | 1/512 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 65) | 1 | 1/512 |
| Mystery box (Court Cases) Using an estimated rarity as not enough data has been submitted. | 1 | Common |
| Mystery box (Court Cases) Using an estimated rarity as not enough data has been submitted. | 6 | Common |
| Nechryael | 1 | 1/512 |
| Nechryael (elite) | 1 | 1/230.4, 3 rolls |
| Nechryael (Heart of Gielinor) | 1 | 1/403.2 |
| Necromancer (Heart of Gielinor) | 1 | 1/403.2 |
| Nikita | 1 | 1/8,192 |
| Nikolai | 1 | 1/8,192 |
| Oak casket | 3 | 4/64 |