| Magpie Estimated rarity may be inaccurate due to a low sample size. | 1 | 66/854 |
| Mahogany casket | 5 | 16/64 |
| Managing Miscellania (Fishing) | 1 | Common |
| Managing Miscellania (Fishing (cooked)) | 1 | Unknown |
| Managing Miscellania (Mining) | 1 | Common |
| Manifest shadow | 1 | 1/141.94 |
| Market Guard (Fremennik) | 1 | 1/528.52 |
| Mighty Blood reaver | 1 | 1/99.92 |
| Milla | 1 | 1/2,114.06 |
| Minotaur | 1 | 1/528.52 |
| Minotaur (Turael's basement) | 1 | 1/528.52 |
| Mithril dragon | 1 | 1/104.88 |
| Molanisk | 1 | 1/75.5 |
| Moss giant | 1 | 1/132.13 |
| Mountain troll | 1 | 1/105.7 |
| Mourner (Mourner Tunnels) | 1 | 1/105.7 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht Pyramid) | 1 | 1/1,059.1 |
| Mummy (Jaldraocht sarcophagus) | 1 | 1/1,059.1 |
| Mummy (Ullek) | 1 | 1/1,059.1 |
| Mutated bloodveld | 1 | 1/52.85 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 58) | 1 | 1/132.13 |
| Mutated zygomite (Level 65) | 1 | 1/132.13 |
| Mystery box (random events) | 1 | Common |
| Nechryael | 1 | 1/132.13 |
| Nechryael (elite) | 1 | 1/59.46, 3 rolls |
| Nechryael (Heart of Gielinor) | 1 | 1/104.05 |
| Necromancer (Heart of Gielinor) | 1 | 1/104.05 |
| Nikita | 1 | 1/2,114.06 |
| Nikolai | 1 | 1/2,114.06 |
| Oak casket | 5 | 16/64 |
| Ogre statue | 1 | 1/260.13 |
| Ork statue | 1 | 1/408.09 |
| Otherworldly being | 1 | 1/178.97 |
| Ourg statue | 1 | 1/194.75 |
| Oyster (Aquarium) Replenishes every week. | 1 | 495/1,000, 5 rolls |
| Paladin | 1 | 1/264.26 |
| Pee Hat | 1 | 1/105.7 |
| Pirate | 1 | 1/528.52 |
| Premier Vault (Ironman Mode) | 2–6 | Varies |
| Prifddinas gem rock | 1 | 220/996 |
| Professor Manglethorp | 8 | Common |
| Professor Onglewip | 1–16 | Uncommon |
| Pyrefiend | 1 | 1/264.26 |
| Pyrefiend (God Wars Dungeon) | 1 | 1/264.26 |
| Rare drop table (Gem table) 32/128 in free-to-play, replacing dragonstone. | 1 | 31/128 |
| Ravenous ghoul | 1 | 1/264.26 |
| Red dragon | 1 | 1/105.7 |
| Reinforced Chest (East Ardougne) | 1 | 286/1,431 |