| Ol' Sawtooth (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Olivia the Chronicler (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Onyx dragon | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Onyx dragon (Dragonkin Laboratory) (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Oreb, the Magister (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Orikalka | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Ork statue | 35–45 | 1/404,821.33 |
| Osseous | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Otherworldly being | 35–45 | 1/177,536.68 |
| Ourg statue | 35–45 | 1/2,972.23 |
| Oyu the Quietest (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Paladin | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Pee Hat | 35–45 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Pirate | 35–45 | 1/524,288 |
| Pirate plunder Estimated rarity may be inaccurate due to a low sample size. | 100 | 6/267 |
| Pirate plunder (small) Estimated rarity may be inaccurate due to a low sample size. | 100 | 6/267 |
| Profane Scabarite | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Pthentraken | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Pyrefiend | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Pyrefiend (God Wars Dungeon) | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Queen Black Dragon | 35–45 | 1/872 |
| Quetzathog (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Raksha, the Shadow Colossus | 40–60 | 12/100 |
| Rare drop table (Rare table) | 35–45 | 2/64 |
| Rasial, the First Necromancer (Normal) | 60 | 8/128 |
| Rathis | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Ravenous ghoul | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Red dragon | 35–45 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Red dragon (Dragonkin Laboratory) (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Renegade Menaphite soldier (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Ripper Demon | 35–45 | 1/3,051.02 |
| Ripper dinosaur | 35–45 | 1/3,200 |
| Risen ghost | 18 | 8/100 |
| Rock | 35–45 | 1/104,857.6 |
| Rock crab | 35–45 | 1/524,288 |
| Rock golem | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Rock lobster | 35–45 | 1/262,144 |
| Rock slug | 35–45 | 1/131,072 |
| Rune dragon | 35–45 | 1/1,600 |
| Salarin the Twisted | 35–45 | 1/524,288 |
| Salawa akh | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Sangri the Red (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Sanguine crawler | 35–45 | 1/65,536 |
| Sarkhan the Serpentspeaker (Normal mode) | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |
| Scabaras lancer | 35–45 | 1/37,449.14, 2 rolls |
| Scabaras mage | 35–45 | 1/37,449.14, 2 rolls |
| Scabaras ranger | 35–45 | 1/37,449.14, 2 rolls |
| Scarab akh | 35–45 | 1/4,800 |