| Skoblin (Strongbones) | 1 | Always |
| Skulls mercenary (Brainwashed) | 1 | Always |
| Small Forgotten Belongings This drop is replaced by oddments for Ironman Mode players. | 5 | 1,881/10,170, 3 rolls |
| Small lizard | 1 | Always |
| Small parcel | 10 | Common |
Smashing Pumpkin (Normal) | 5 | 1,647/19,501 |
| Snake | 1 | Always |
| Snake (Ape Atoll) | 1 | Always |
| Soldier (Yanille) | 1 | Always |
Sorebones | 1 | Always |
| Soulless | 1 | Always |
| Sparkling glyph | 1 | Unknown |
| Specimen tray | 1 | Common |
| Speedy Keith | 1 | Always |
| Spidine | 1 | Always |
| Spotted kebbit | 1 | Always |
| Squiggles | 1 | Always |
| Stag | 1 | Always |
| Stag (Enchanted Valley) | 1 | Always |
| Starlight | 1 | Always |
| Stinkears | 1 | Always |
| Strawberry cow (player-owned farm teaser) | 1 | Always |
| Summoned Zombie | 1 | Always |
| Swamp frog | 1 | Always |
| Swarming turoth | 1 | Always |
| Swordchick | 1 | Always |
| Taraket the Necromancer (Normal mode) | 1 | Always |
| Taraket the Necromancer (Story mode) | 1 | Always |
| Tarik (Nardah) | 1 | Always |
| Tentacle (A Shadow over Ashdale) Typically not dropped in practice because the tentacles retreat at 1 LP. | 4 | Always |
| Terror dog (Level 61) | 1 | Always |
| Terrorbird | 1 | Always |
| The Ambassador (Normal mode) | 1 | Always |
| The Ambassador (Story mode) | 1 | Always |
| The Kendal | 1 | Always |
| The Sanctum Guardian (Normal mode) | 1 | Always |
| The Sanctum Guardian (Story mode) | 1 | Always |
| Thief | 1 | Always |
| Thing under the bed | 1 | Always |
| Thora (Miscellania Castle) | 1 | Always |
| Thorhild | 1 | Always |
| Thug | 1 | Always |
| Tough Guy | 1 | Always |
| Tower guard | 1 | Always |
| Trade floor guard | 1 | Always |
| Trahaearn automaton mk III | 1 | Always |
| Trahaearn automaton mk IV | 1 | Always |
| Translator | 1 | Always |