| Sakadagami | 25–75 | 1/100 |
| Sarkhan the Serpentspeaker (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/17.1 |
| Scorpion (Uncharted Isles) | 2–5 | 64/128 |
| Sea crocodile (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/55.6 |
| Seasinger priestess | 4–7 | 64/128 |
| Seiryu the Azure Serpent (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/17.1 |
| Skeleton (Uncharted Isles) | 2–5 | 64/128 |
| Skulls mercenary (Uncharted Isles) | 2–5 | 64/128 |
| Sotapanna | 25–50 | 1/100 |
| The Sanctum Guardian (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/17.1 |
| The Violet Lotus (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/17.1 |
| Tormented soul (Uncharted Isles) | 2–5 | 64/128 |
| Tortle | — | Uncommon |
| Treasure chest (player-owned port) | 500–5,000 | 1/923 |
| Uncharted Isles | 10–25 | Common |
| Uncharted Isles | 100–500 | Rare |
| Waiko islander (Pickpocketing) | 1 | 1/10 |
| Waterfiend (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/74.1 |
Wythien | 500–5,000 | 1/308 |
| Xiang the Water-shaper (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/17.1 |
| Yukimura of Hanto (Normal mode) | 100–200 | 1/17.1 |
| Zombie (Uncharted Isles) | 2–4 | 64/128 |